Article Content
Abstract
The stabilization of coastal sand dunes in the 20th century led to an expansion of vegetation cover, which is considered detrimental in the United Kingdom due to the loss of habitat for native species that depend on mobile dunes. Coastal managers have recognized this as a growing concern. However, conservation priorities must be identified to manage the situation effectively. Therefore, this study aims to identify potential conservation priorities for dune habitats at Culbin (Scotland), Kenfig (Wales) and the Sefton coast (England) by undertaking a SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats) analysis for each site. Variables for the analysis were identified in the context of the latest paradigm of dune management approach, which focuses on the reclamation of active dunes to enhance habitats for native biodiversity. Data was obtained from literature; analysis of environmental, demographic, land use and economic data; and satellite images. The main challenges that emerged include historical overstabilization, the spread of invasive species, the lack of bare sand areas to sustain native biodiversity, unsustainable land use (unplanned urbanization and agricultural activities), coastal erosion due to storm surges, and sea-level rise in this century. Accordingly, potential conservation priorities were determined by classifying variables of each site. These include increasing the area of bare sand, increasing the width of the beach using sand nourishments, removing invasive species, minimizing human activities to reduce dune fragmentation, minimizing coastal erosion due to storm surge and sea-level rise using nature-based solutions. Thus, an integrated sustainable dune management plan is required to implement these conservation priorities, particularly for Culbin dunes as the Cumulative SWOT Score shows that the weaknesses and threats to dunes outweigh strength and opportunities. The study approach demonstrates its robustness as a decision-making tool for sustainable dune management for restoring active dunes at each site. Thus, it can be extended to other dune sites in the UK and elsewhere to identify long-term dune management concerns and conservation priorities.
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles and news from researchers in related subjects, suggested using machine learning.
- Coastal Sciences
- Conservation and Preservation
- Environmental Archaeology
- Environmental Policy
- Environmental Management
- Heritage Management
Data availability
No datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
References
-
Arens S, Quirinus S, Geelen L, Van der Hagen H (2013) Restoration of Dune Mobility in the Netherlands. In Restoration of Coastal Dunes, edited by ML Martínez, J Gallego-Fernández, and P Hesp. Berlin-Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.
-
Ariza E (2011) An analysis of beach management framework in Spain. Study case: The Catalonian coast. J Coast Conserv 15(4):445–455.
-
Barnes AP, Svensson C, Kjeldsen TR (2022) North Atlantic air pressure and temperature conditions associated with heavy rainfall in Great Britain. Int J Climatol 42(5):3190–3207.
-
Bauer BO, Davidson-Arnott RGD (2002) A general framework for modeling sediment supply to coastal dunes including wind angle, beach geometry, and fetch effects. Geomorphology 49(1):89–108.
-
BC (2008) Habitats Regulations Assessment of the Bridgend Local Development Plan – Pre-Deposit Proposals Screening assessment. BRIDGEND COUNTY, BOROUGH COUNCIL
-
Bezzi A, Pillon S, Martinucci D, Fontolan G (2018) Inventory and conservation assessment for the management of coastal dunes, Veneto coasts, Italy. J Coast Conserv 22:503–518.
-
Brazier V, Bruneau PMC, Gordon JE, Rennie AF (2012) Making Space for Nature in a Changing Climate: The Role of Geodiversity in Biodiversity Conservation. Scott Geographical J 128(3–4):211–233. September–December 2012.
-
Bridges TS, King JK, Simm JD, Beck MW, Collins G, Lodder Q, Mohan RK eds. (2021) International Guidelines on Natural and Nature-Based Features for Flood Risk Management. Vicksburg, MS: U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center.
-
Bull JW, Jobstvogt N, Bohnke-Henrichs A, Mascarenhas A, Sitas N, Baulcomb C, Lambini CK, Rawlins M, Baral H, Zahringer J, Carter-Silk E, Balzan MV, Kenter JO, Hayha T, Petz K, Koss R (2016) Strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats; a SWOT analysis of the ecosystem services framework. Ecosyst Serv 17:99–111.
-
Burden A, Smeaton C, Angus S, Garbutt A, Jones L, Lewis HD, Rees SM (2020) Impacts of climate change on coastal habitats relevant to the coastal and marine environment around the UK. MCCIP Sci Rev 2020, 228 255.
-
Campbell C, Hodgetts N, Lockhart N (2013) Petalophyllum ralfsii (Wils.) Nees & Gottsche (Petalwort) in the Republic of Ireland. Article 17 Report Backing Document. National Parks and Wildlife Service.
-
CCW (2008) Core Management Plan for Kenfig / Cynffig SAC. Countryside Council for Wales, Bangor
-
Chock, R. Y., Miller, W. B., King, S. N. D., Brehme, C. S., Fisher, R. N., Sin, H., Wilcox, P., Terp, J., Tremor, S., Major, M. R., Merrill, K., Spencer, W. D., Sullivan, S., & Shier, D. M. (2022) Quantitative SWOT analysis: A structured and collaborative approach to reintroduction site selection for the endangered Pacific pocket mouse. Journal for Nature Conservation, 70,10pp. 126268. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnc.2022.126268
-
Clarke ML, Rendell HM (2011) Atlantic storminess and historical sand drift in Western Europe: implications for future management of coastal dunes. J Coast Conserv 15:227–236.
-
Cohn N, Ruggiero P, de Vries S, Kaminsky GM (2018) New insights on coastal foredune growth: The relative contributions of marine and aeolian processes. Geophys Res Lett 45:4965–4973.
-
Condeça J, Pinheiro I, da Silva MO, Chambel A (2006) Groundwater modelling in atlantic coastal ecosystems (south portugal). In: Baba, A, Howard, KWF, Gunduz, O (eds) Groundwater and Ecosystems., vol 70. Springer, Dordrecht.
-
Collins MB, Banner FT (1980) Sediment transport by waves and tides: problems exemplified by a study of Swansea Bay, Bristol Channel. In: Banner FT, Collins MB, Massie KS (eds) The north-west European shelf seas: the seabed and the sea in motion II. Physical and chemical oceanography, and physical Resources. Elsevier Scientific Publishing company, Amsterdam. pp 369-389
-
Comber DPM (1993) Shoreline response to relative sea-level change: Culbin Sands, North-east Scotland. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Glasgow.
-
Coman A, Ronen B (2009) Focused SWOT: diagnosing critical strengths and weaknesses. Int J Prod Res 47(20):5677–5689.
-
Dandapath PK (2021) SWOT analysis on coastal forest resources and enhancing ecotourism potentiality: A study on coastal West Bengal in India. Int J Multidisciplinary Trends 3(1): 338-345
-
Dang KB, Nguyen TT, Ngo HH, Burkhard B, Müller F, Dang VB, Nguyen H, Ngo VL, Pham TPN (2021) Integrated methods and scenarios for assessment of sand dunes ecosystem services. J Environ Manag 289:112485.
-
DD (2021) Dynamic Dunescapes – Media release ‘Notches’ in sand dunes created to boost biodiversity on the Sefton Coast. Sefton Coast, Dynamic Dunescapes, https://dynamicdunescapes.co.uk/project/sefton-coast/
-
DEFRA 2005 CRR Research Report No. 14: The wider social impacts of changes in the structure of agricultural businesses Final Report For Defra Matt Lobley, Clive Potter, Allan Butler With Ian Whitehead and Nick
-
Delgado-Fernandez I (2010) A review of the application of the fetch effect to mod elling sand supply to coastal foredunes. Aeolian Res 2(2-3):61–70.
-
Dissanayake P, Brown J, Karunarathna H (2015) Impacts of storm chronology on the morphological changes of the Formby beach and dune system, UK. Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci 15:1533–1543.
-
Durán O, Moor LJ (2013) Vegetation controls on the maximum size of coastal dunes. Atmos, Planet Sciencesecology, Pnas 110(43):17217–17222. EARTH.
-
Edmondson SE (2010) Dune Slacks on the Sefton Coast, Sefton’s Dynamic Coast, Proceeding of the conference on coastal and geomorphology, Biogeogr Manag 178–187.
-
Einsele G (1993) Marine depositional events controlled by sediment supply and sea-level changes. Geologische Rundsch 82:173–184.
-
Esteves LS, Brown JM, Williams JJ, Lymbery G (2012) Quantifying thresholds for significant dune erosion along the Sefton. Coast Northwest Engl Geomorphol 143:52–61.
-
Feagin RA, Sherman DJ, Grant WE (2005) Coastal erosion, global sea-level rise, and the loss of sand dune plant habitats. Front Ecol Environ 3:359–364.
-
Freitas JG (2020) Making a Case for an Environmental History of Dunes. Anthropocenes – Hum, Inhuman, Posthuman 1(1):5.
-
Freitas JG (2022) Contar histórias de dunas na escola: o litoral e as mudanças ambientais. Ambient Educção 25(3):224–250.
-
Freitas, JG, 2024 A Global Environmental History of Coastal Dunes. Routledge, London.
-
Görener A, Toker K, Uluçay K (2012) Case Study for a Manufacturing Firm. Procedia – Soc Behav Sci 58:1525–1534.
-
Gray T (1909) The Buried City of Kenfig, New York.
-
Gresswell RK (1937) The geomorphology of the southwest Lancashire coastline. Geogr J 90:35–349.
-
Griffiths D (2011) The Archaeology of Sand Landscapes: Looking for an Integrated Approach. Scott Archaeol Internet Rep 48:9–24.
-
Hansom JD, Rennie AF, Fitton JM (2017) Dynamic Coast – National Coastal Change Assessment: Cell 3 – Cairnbulg Point to Duncansby Head, CRW2014/2.
-
Helms MM, Nixon JC (2010) Exploring SWOT analysis – where are we now? A review of academic research from the last decade. J strategy Manag 3(3):215–251.
-
Hesp PA (2002) Foredunes and blowouts: initiation, geomorphology and dynamics. Geomorphology 48:245–268.
-
Hesp P (2011) Dune Coasts. In: Wolanski E and McLusky DS (eds.) Treatise on Estuarine and Coastal Science, Vol 3, pp. 193–221. Waltham: Academic Press.
-
Howe MA, Litt E, Pye K (2012) Rejuvenating Welsh dunes. Brit Wildl 24:95–94.
-
IPCC (2021): Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2391 pp.
-
Jackson DWT, Costa S, González-Villanueva R, Cooper A (2019) A global ‘greening’ of coastal dunes: An integrated consequence of climate change?. Glob Planet Change 182:103026.
-
Jackson DWT, Cooper A, Green A, Beyers M, Guisado-Pintado E, Wiles E, Benallack K, Balme M (2020) Reversing transverse dunes: Modelling of airflow switching using 3D computational fluid dynamics. Earth Planet Sci Lett 543:116363.
-
JNCC (2015) UK Approach’ to updating the UK’s Natura 2000 Standard Data Forms. Joint Nature Conservation Committee. (JNCC) https://hub.jncc.gov.uk/assets/a3d9da1e-dedc-4539-a574-84287636c898
-
Jones MLM, Sowerby A, Williams DL, Jones RE (2008) Factors controlling soil development in sand dunes: evidence from a coastal dune soil chronosequence. Plant Soil 307:219–234.
-
Jones PS, Farr G, Low R, Etherington JR (2017) Ecohydrological studies of dune slack vegetation at Kenfig dunes, South Wales, UK. J Coast Conserv 21:623–630.
-
Lamy A, Robin N, Smyth TAG, Hesp P, René C, Feyssat P, Raynal O, Hebert B (2024) Impact of temporal beach grain size variability on aeolian sediment transport and topographic evolution in a microtidal environment. Geomorphology 453:109126. pp.
-
Malvárez G, Ferreira O, Navas F, Cooper JAG, Gracia-Prieto FJ, Talavera L (2021) Storm impacts on a coupled human-natural coastal system: Resilience of developed coasts. Sci Total Environ 768:144987.
-
Mauz B, Hijma MP, Amorosi A, Porat N, Galili E, Bloemendal J (2013) Aeolian Beach Ridges and Their Significance for Climate and Sea Level: Concept and Insight from the Levant Coast (East Mediterranean). Earth Sci Rev 121:31–54.
-
McGranahan G, Balk D, Anderson B (2007) The rising tide: assessing the risks of climate change and human settlements in low elevation coastal zones. Environ urbanization 19(1):17–37.
-
Natura (2000, 2016). Outline of a roadmap for knowledge exchange and networking for the period 2016-2020, Conservation of dune habitats in the Atlantic Biogeographic Region. http://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/natura2000/platform/documents/263/Roadmap_for_dunes_of_the_Atlantic_Region_v_Jan2017_en.pdf.
-
NatureScot (2005) Culbin bar special area of conservation (SAC) conservation package.
-
North FJ (1964) The evolution of the Bristol Channel. National Museums of Wales, Cardiff, 110
-
NT (2014) How have the storms affected the coast? The National Trust – coast & countryside, available at: http://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/article-1355824158683/
-
Orford JD, Wilson P, Wintle AG, Knight J, Braley S (2000) Holocene Coastal Dune Initiation in Northumberland and Norfolk, Eastern UK: Climate and Sea-Level Changes as Possible Forcing Agents for Dune Initiation. Geol Soc Lond Spec Publ 166:197–217.
-
Odériz I, Knöchelmann N, Silva R, Feagin RA, Martínez ML, Mendoza E (2020) Reinforcement of vegetated and unvegetated dunes by a rocky core: A viable alternative for dissipating waves and providing protection?. Coast Eng 158:103675.
-
Oosthoek K (2018) Origins and development of state forestry in the United Kingdom. In: Oosthoek, K and Holzl, R (eds.), Managing Northern Europe’s Forests. Histories from the Age of Improvement to the Age of Ecology. New York: Berghahn Books.
-
Parkinson RW, Ogurcak DE (2018) Beach nourishment is not a sustainable strategy to mitigate climate change. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci 212:203–209.
-
Provoost S, Jones MLM, Edmondson SE (2011) Changes in landscape and vegetation of coastal dunes in northwest Europe: a review. J Coast Conserv 15:207–226.
-
Pye K, Neal A (1993) Late Holocene dune formation on the Sefton coast, northwest England. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 72, 201–217.
-
Pye K, Neal A (1994) Coastal dune erosion at Formby Point, north Merseyside, England: causes and mechanisms. Mar Geol 119(1–2):39–56.
-
Pye K, Blott SJ (2008) Decadal-scale variation in dune erosion and accretion rates: an investigation of the significance of changing storm tide frequency and magnitude on the Sefton coast, UK. Geomorphology 102:652–666.
-
Pye K, Blott SJ (2013) Kenfig dune restoration works phase 1. Overview report, 30 July 2013. Evidence report no. 43. Natural Resources Wales, Bangor
-
Pye K, Blott SJ, Howe MA (2014) Coastal dune stabilization in Wales and requirements for rejuvenation. J Coast Conserv 18:27–54.
-
Pye K, Blott SJ (2017) Evolution of a sediment-starved, over-stabilised dunefield: Kenfig Burrows, South Wales, UK. J Coast Conserv 21:685–717.
-
Rayment M, Christie M (2011) Benefits of Sites of Special Scientific Interest. : GHK Consulting report for Defra
-
Rennie AF, Hansom JD (2011) Sea level trend reversal: Land uplift outpaced by sea level rise on Scotland’s coast. 125 (1),193-202.
-
Rhind P, Blackstock TH, Hardy HS, Jones RE, Sandison W (2001) The evolution of the Newborough Warren dune system with particular reference to the past four decades. In: Houston, JA, Edmondson, SE Rooney, PJ (eds.) Coastal dune management – shared experiences of European conservation practice. pp. 345–379.
-
Richardson RB, Nicholls S (2021) Characterizing the cultural ecosystem services of coastal sand dunes. J Gt Lakes Res 47(2):546–551.
-
Ross S (1992) The Culbin Sands— fact and fiction. University of Aberdeen, Centre for Scottish Studies, Aberdeen.
-
Sampath DMR, Freitas JG, Dias JA (2022) Extending the DPSIR framework to analyse Driver-Pressure-State-Impact-Response of sand dune management in Manawatu-Whanganui (New Zealand) as a time series. Ocean Coast Manag 230:106348.
-
Sampath DMR, Beattie J, Freitas JG (2023) Managing coastal sand drift in the Anthropocene: A case study of the Manawatū-Whanganui Dune Field, New Zealand, 1800s-2020s. Environ Hist 29(3):423–448. https://doi.org/10.3197/096734021X16328497562933.
-
Sanò M (2002) Quantitative SWOT Analysis Applied To Beach Environments: A Tool For Integrated Coastal Area Management. Case studies: The Corralejo And Jandia Beaches, Canary Island. graduate dissertation: Dipartimento per lo studio del Territorio e delle sue Risorse (Dip.Te.Ris.) Università di Genova (IT).
-
Saye SE, van der Wal D, Pye K, Blott SJ (2005) Beach – dune morphological relationships and erosion / accretion: an investigation at five sites in England and Wales using LIDAR data. Geomorphology 72:128–155.
-
SC (1998) Sefton Coast Management Plan. Sefton Council 1998
-
SC (2017) Local Plan for Sefton April 2017 Sefton Council. Sefton Coast, Dynamic Dunescapes, https://dynamicdunescapes.co.uk/project/sefton-coast/
-
Scapini F et al. (2002) Baseline Research for the Integrated Sustainable Management of Mediterranean Sensitive Coastal Ecosystems, Ed. Istituto Agronomico per l’Oltremare.
-
Schoenleber C, D’Antonio A, Hall TE (2022) Are signs enough?. Using Norm narrative messaging Prot West snowy plover (Charadrius nivosus) Coast Or 28:126251.
-
Scolozzi R, Schirpke U, Morri E, D’Amato D, Santolini R (2014) Ecosystem services-based SWOT analysis of protected areas for conservation strategies. J Environ Manag 146:543–551.
-
Silva GF, Wijnberg KM, de Groot AV, Hulscher SJMH (2019) The effects of beach width variability on coastal dune development at decadal scales. Geomorphology 329:58–69.
-
Sloss CR, Hesp P, Shepherd M (2012a) Coastal Dunes: Aeolian Transport. Nat Educ Knowl 3(10):21.
-
Sloss CR, Shepherd M, Hesp P (2012b) Coastal Dunes: Geomorphology. Nat Educ Knowl 3(10):2.
-
Smith PH (2014) Effects of winter storm surge on the Sefton Coast, north Merseyside, Sand Dune and Shingle Network Eighteenth Newsletter, March 2014, Linking science and management, Liverpool Hope University.
-
SNH (2011) Culbin Sands, Culbin Forest and Findhorn Bay Site of Special Scientific Interest. Site Management Statement, Site code: 478. Scottish Natural Heritage.
-
SNH (2017) Taking an adaptive approach: sea level rise and restoring the natural mobility of the Culbin sand dunes. Scottish Natural Heritage. Climate change adaptation case study #6
-
Staudt F, Gijsman R, Ganal C, Mielck F, Wolbring J, Hass HC, Goseberg N, Schüttrumpf H, Schlurmann T, Schimmels S (2021) The sustainability of beach nourishments: a review of nourishment and environmental monitoring practice. J Coast Conserv 25(2):34.
-
Sutton-Grier AE, Wowk K, Bamford H (2015) Future of our coasts: the potential for natural and hybrid infrastructure to enhance the resilience of our coastal communities, economies and ecosystems. Environ Sci Policy 51:137–148.
-
Tsoar H, Cohen-Zada AL (2020) The conflict between urban planning and the preservation of sand dunes – The case of the Big Dune in the city of Ashdod, Israel. City Environ Interact 5:100034. Article.
-
van Puijenbroek MEB, Nolet C, de Groot AV, Suomalainen JM, Riksen MJPM, Berendse F, Limpens J (2017) Exploring the contributions of vegetation and dune size to early dune development using unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) imaging. Biogeosciences 14:5533–5549.
-
Vina MA, Sampath DMR, Freitas J (2024) Patchy Anthropocoasts: A transdisciplinary perspective on dunes, plants, rabbits, and humans in the United Kingdom. Shima 18(1):132–148.
-
Wessex Archaeology (2012) Kenfig, Bridgend, Glamorgan, South Wales. Archaeological evaluation and assessment of results. Report to Videotext Communications Ltd, Cardiff. Wessex Archaeology, Salisbury, March 2012, 41 pp.
-
Wilkinson K (2006) Kenfig SAC: Summary SAC Monitoring Report.
-
Williams JJ, Brown J, Esteves LS, Souza A (2011) MICORE WP4 Modelling coastal erosion and flooding along the Sefton Coast NW UK, final report. http://www.micore.eu
-
Winter C, Ruessink BG (2017) Sensitivity analysis of climate change impacts on dune erosion: a case study for the Dutch Holland coast R. Clim Change 141:685–701. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-017-1922-3.
-
Zhang L, Baas ACW (2012) Mapping functional vegetation attributes in a coastal dune environment using a combination of LSMA and MLD: a case study at Kenfig NNR, Wales. Int J Remote Sens 33:5043–5071.
Acknowledgements
This article is an output of the project DUNES, funded by the European Research Council under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Program (grant no. 802918). The article also benefited from a research stay at the Linda Hall Library, Kansas City, USA, where J.G. Freitas was a Fellow in 2014.
Funding
The project is funded by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Program (Grant agreement n°802918). However, all authors declare that the study is not influenced by any institution that supported financial grants and there is no personal influence by any person whatsoever.
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
About this article
Cite this article
Sampath, D.M.R., Vina, M. & Freitas, J.G.d. An Analysis of Dune Management on the Kenfig, Culbin and Sefton Coasts in the UK Using the SWOT Framework. Environmental Management (2025). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-025-02210-5
- Received
- Accepted
- Published
- DOI https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-025-02210-5
Keywords
- Coastal dunes
- Dune over-stabilization
- SWOT framework
- Dune restoration
- Biodiversity